Wander Beauty Mile High Club Mascara Review
I’m a little obsessed with finding the perfect mascara. Long, fluttery lashes that look natural yet dramatic are my ultimate goal, and I’m constantly on the hunt for a product that delivers. Is it too much to ask for a mascara that defines, lengthens, and volumizes without clumping or flaking? After hearing rave reviews from beauty enthusiasts about Wander Beauty Mile High Club Mascara, I decided it was time to give it a try. Spoiler alert: it might just be the one.
Here’s the backstory: I’ve tried dozens of mascaras over the years, ranging from drugstore gems to luxury splurges. While some delivered great results, there was always a catch—whether it was smudging by midday, clumps that resembled spider legs, or formulas that required a chisel to remove. I wanted something versatile and reliable, and when I stumbled across the Mile High Club mascara, it seemed to tick all the boxes.
First Impressions
The first thing that struck me was the sleek, golden tube. Wander Beauty is known for its minimalist yet elegant aesthetic, and this mascara fits right in. The tube feels lightweight but sturdy, making it perfect for tossing in a travel bag or everyday makeup pouch. The branding promises “length, definition, and lift in a single swipe,” which sounded almost too good to be true.
The wand itself is slim with evenly spaced bristles. This design immediately made me think it would excel at precision—coating every lash without creating clumps. The formula is advertised as smudge-proof, flake-proof, and infused with nourishing ingredients like castor seed oil, which is known to promote lash health.
Application
When I first pulled the wand out of the tube, I was impressed by how evenly the product coated the bristles. No excessive gunk or blobs—a promising start! On my first swipe through my lashes, I noticed how lightweight the formula felt. It didn’t weigh down my lashes, even after a couple of coats.
The real magic, though, is in the wand. The slim brush allowed me to reach every lash, even the tiny ones in the inner corners of my eyes. I’m someone who struggles with mascaras that can’t reach those hard-to-access areas without smudging, so this was a big win for me. Each lash was coated evenly, creating a clean, fanned-out effect.
I applied two coats, which gave me the length and definition I’d been craving. The result wasn’t overly dramatic, making it perfect for everyday wear, but it was buildable enough to give more impact for a night out. And true to its name, the mascara gave my lashes a “mile-high” lift that stayed in place all day.
Wear Test
After the initial application, I was eager to see how the Wander Beauty Mile High Club Mascara would hold up over the course of a busy day. My schedule included running errands, a workout, and a dinner date—plenty of opportunities for the mascara to flake, smudge, or disappoint.
By the end of the day, I was genuinely impressed. Not a single smudge or flake in sight. My lashes still looked as defined and lifted as they did in the morning. Even after a humid workout session, the mascara stayed put without any raccoon eyes—a rarity in my experience. This performance is likely due to its water-resistant formula, which strikes the perfect balance between longevity and ease of removal.
Removal
Speaking of removal, I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to take off the Mile High Club Mascara. I’ve used water-resistant mascaras in the past that required aggressive scrubbing, leaving my lashes feeling brittle and my eyes irritated. Not the case here. A gentle swipe with micellar water or a cleansing balm dissolved the mascara completely, with no tugging or leftover residue.
Ingredients
One standout feature of this mascara is its lash-loving formula. It’s enriched with nourishing ingredients like castor seed oil, which is celebrated for its ability to strengthen lashes and promote growth. The formula also includes glycerin and panthenol, which help to hydrate and condition the lashes. Over the month I’ve been using this mascara, I’ve noticed my lashes feeling softer and less prone to breakage—a welcome bonus.
Versatility
Another aspect I loved about this mascara is how versatile it is. For a subtle, natural look, one coat is enough to enhance your lashes without looking overdone. Add a second or third coat, and you’ve got a more dramatic, voluminous effect that’s perfect for evening wear. Unlike some mascaras that clump with additional layers, the Mile High Club Mascara remains smooth and buildable.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
Lightweight formula that doesn’t weigh down lashes
Slim wand for precise application
Smudge-proof and flake-proof, even during long wear
Nourishing ingredients that promote lash health
Easy to remove without harsh scrubbing
Buildable for both natural and dramatic looks
Cons:
The price point ($26) may be a bit steep for some
Limited to one shade (black), which may not suit all preferences
Final Thoughts
In my opinion, the Wander Beauty Mile High Club Mascara lives up to its glowing reputation. It’s rare to find a mascara that checks all the boxes, but this one truly does. It’s a dream for anyone who values length, definition, and long-lasting wear without compromising lash health.
While it’s on the pricier side, the quality and performance justify the cost. Plus, the added lash care benefits make it feel more like an investment in your natural lashes rather than just another makeup product.
If you’re tired of mascaras that smudge, flake, or clump, I highly recommend giving this one a try. Whether you’re headed to work, the gym, or a glamorous evening event, the Mile High Club Mascara has got your back (and lashes) covered.