12 Best Mascara Primers for When One Coat Isn’t Quite Enough
Your mascara already gives you the color you want, so what would another layer actually do? Take a look at where the finished coat falls short. Lashes can look dark enough and still need a little body through the middle. Straight lashes can lose the bend you just put in with a curler. Those are two good reasons to reach for a primer.
The base should do the part your mascara leaves unfinished. Fine fibers can add body, a fixer can help keep a curl in place, and a tinted primer can make a separate coat of mascara optional. Check how the formula sets before you buy, too. A primer you need to coat while it’s wet changes the way you do both eyes. Below are the 12 best mascara primers to pair with the mascara you already love, plus a few tinted picks that can stand on their own.
Our Top Picks
Best Overall
Best Budget
Best Drugstore
Best to Wear Alone
Best Tubing Formula
Best Waterproof
Best Fragrance-Free
Best Primer and Topcoat
Best for Precise Application
Best for Buildable Volume
Best for Curl Hold
Best for Conditioning
Best Overall
Lancôme Cils Booster XL
Formula: White fiber base | Layering: Apply mascara while the base is wet | Size: 0.18 oz
If your mascara gives you definition but leaves your lashes looking fine, this is a good all-around base. Fine fibers give lashes more visible length and body from the first layer. Both are useful when the mascara you already like gets the shade and finish right, and you want a fuller look from it.
Have the mascara open before you start. Layer it onto the primer while the base is still wet, then check the short lashes at the corners for any white showing through. Those are the spots to touch up before you add another coat across the whole lash line.
Best Budget
Essence Lash Princess Mascara Primer Extra Length & Volume
Formula: Light green primer | Applicator: Flexible elastomer wand | Size: 0.30 fl oz / 9 mL
The mint tint helps you see where a first coat ends on fine lashes. It also makes it easy to tell if you’ve missed a spot before you cover it with mascara. A flexible wand gives you some control over how much goes on when you’re learning to layer two formulas.
Let the primer dry before you add mascara. Start with a single even layer and see how much extra length and body you get from your usual mascara. A second primer coat is an option when you’re after a more pronounced result.
Best Drugstore
L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Primer
Formula: White volumizing primer | Layering: Finish one eye at a time | Size: 0.24 fl oz
When the mascara you already own gives you a shape you like, a classic white base lets you keep that brush and build a fuller look underneath. Voluminous is a straightforward pairing for a dark volumizing mascara. You can add some body through the lashes without changing the brush that gives your usual makeup its shape.
Finish one eye at a time. Apply primer and follow with mascara before it dries, then move to the other side. This keeps the white base fresh for the second coat, even if you usually prime both eyes before reaching for mascara.
Best to Wear Alone
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Tinted Primer
Formula: Soft black tinted primer | Layering: Let the primer dry before mascara | Size: 0.26 fl oz
Some mornings a little color is enough. Soft black gives bare lashes definition, so you can leave the primer on its own when you want the lash line to show with minimal makeup. The slim, flexible brush also gives you room to work on the shorter lashes at the outside corners.
For extra length, let the tint dry before adding mascara. Pair it with washable Sky High if you already use that mascara. Keep your usual application on the first try so you can see what the primer adds.
Best Tubing Formula
Tartelette Tubing Lash Primer
Formula: White tubing primer | Layering: Wait a few seconds before mascara | Size: 0.27 fl oz / 8 mL
Tubing primers coat individual lashes with a film that wraps around them. Here, that layer builds definition before you add color. Work the wand between lashes where they sit close together, so the base reaches those spots before you move on to mascara.
Wait a few seconds before following with the matching tubing mascara. Keep your usual removal routine in mind as you layer. The formula on top still matters, so a tubing base under a conventional waterproof mascara won’t give you the same removal routine as a tubing mascara on its own.
Best Waterproof
Too Faced Better Than Sex Foreplay Mascara Primer
Formula: Waterproof black primer | Removal: Waterproof eye makeup remover | Size: 0.27 fl oz / 8 mL
Waterproof wear starts at the base with this one. The deep black pigment also saves you the work of hiding a pale primer under another coat. That makes it practical as a single step for lash definition, especially if you want waterproof makeup and have little time to layer.
For a waterproof pairing, give the primer up to ten seconds to set before brushing on waterproof mascara. Even worn alone, the waterproof primer calls for a remover made for waterproof eye makeup. Consider that trade-off if a quick evening cleanse matters as much to you as a waterproof base.
Best Fragrance-Free
Clinique Lash Building Primer
Formula: Fragrance-free conditioning primer | Pairing: Use with non-tubing mascara | Size: 0.16 fl oz / 4.8 mL
This fragrance-free base is for readers who prefer eye makeup without added scent. Glycerin and panthenol are part of its conditioning formula. Finish your primer and mascara in quick succession, while the base is still fresh.
Check the mascara you wear most often. Leave this primer out of a tubing mascara routine, including Lash Power or High Impact Zero Gravity. That compatibility detail matters if you’re buying a base to work with a favorite you already use.
Best Primer and Topcoat
Estée Lauder Little Black Primer
Formula: Black tinted primer | Also Works As: Water-resistant topcoat | Size: 0.20 fl oz / 6 mL
Little Black Primer gives you a choice about where the extra layer goes. Under mascara, the dark tint gets color into the lashes from the start. Over it, the same product serves as a water-resistant finishing coat. It’s a useful option when you like the shape your usual mascara makes and want a way to set it.
For a minimal look, run a little of the tint through the roots of bare lashes. Keep most of the color close to the lash line when that’s where you want extra definition. A light coat makes the tint a one-step option on mornings when you’re skipping both eyeliner and mascara.
Best for Precise Application
IT Cosmetics Tightline 3-in-1 Black Lash Primer
Formula: Black tinted primer | Applicator: Ultra-slim brush | Size: 0.12 fl oz / 3.5 mL
Short lashes at the inner corner can be awkward to reach once a full mascara brush is loaded. A narrow wand gives you room to deposit black pigment near the roots and work a few lashes at a time. It’s especially useful when you want a fuller-looking lash line with less emphasis on the tips.
Use it beneath a lengthening mascara if you want definition through the full lash. A light coat of primer on its own can also make the lash line look darker when you skip pencil. The narrow brush makes it easier to limit the color to that small area.
Best for Buildable Volume
MACStack Legit Lift Lash Primer
Formula: Buildable lifting primer | Applicator: Curler-shaped brush | Size: 0.41 fl oz / 12 mL
Buildable volume gives you room to decide how bold you want your lashes to look after the first coat. The curler-shaped brush is designed to reach close to the roots so you can coat the length of the lash. Stop at one pass for a lighter base or keep layering beneath mascara.
Concentrate the second pass where you want the eye to look fullest. More definition through the center can make the lash line look rounder, while building up the outer lashes emphasizes their sweep. Keep your mascara the same and adjust where you build the underlying coat.
Best for Curl Hold
ETUDE Dr. Mascara Fixer #01 Natural
Formula: Curl-setting base | Shade: #01 Natural | Size: 0.21 oz / 6 g
When freshly curled lashes start pointing down again, the first coat can help preserve the bend. This fixer forms a coating over the shape you’ve already made with your curler. That comes in handy when you like the volume of your mascara and want longer-lasting curl from the base.
Curl clean lashes first, then apply the Natural version from the roots before mascara. Follow the bend you’ve made as you brush up through the lashes. You can keep the mascara step as light as you normally wear it.
Best for Conditioning
Diorshow Maximizer 4D
Formula: Balm-textured primer serum | Also Works As: Overnight lash conditioner | Size: 0.34 fl oz / 10 mL
A balm-textured primer serum makes conditioning part of the mascara step. You can also apply it directly to clean lashes before bed. That second use gives the formula a purpose on days when you want conditioning without lash makeup.
Use the angled brush to work along the curve of the lash line, particularly where shorter lashes are easy to miss. Follow immediately with mascara while the primer is still wet. If you do your eyes in stages, finish the lashes before moving on to liner or brows.
FAQ
1. Do You Really Need a Mascara Primer?
Skip it if you already like the shape and fullness you get from your mascara. When you’re unsure, try primer on one eye and use the same mascara on both. Compare the lashes once they’ve dried, then check them again later in the day. That side-by-side look tells you if the extra step makes a difference you care about.
2. Should Mascara Primer Dry Before You Apply Mascara?
The timing depends on the formula. With Lancôme Cils Booster XL, finish one eye at a time so you can apply mascara over the base while it’s still wet. With Maybelline Sky High Tinted Primer, let the base dry first. Check the directions for your primer before you decide how long to wait.


